Singer, a prolific, widely read thinker, mostly applies a utilitarian perspective to controversial moral issues for example, euthanasia, the treatment of nonhuman animals, and global poverty rather than discussing utilitarian moral theory. Utilitarianism is a family of consequentialist ethical theories that promotes actions that maximize happiness and wellbeing for the affected individuals. Utilitarianism and recourse to war volume 23 issue 4 william h. Uwp it is morally right for a state to wage war if and only if no other course of action available to it has greater expected wellbeing, otherwise, waging war is wrong. Just war theory deals with the justification of how and why wars are fought. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war addresses the two basic ethical questions posed by war. This article takes some preliminary steps toward remedying this situation. For instance, consider that the money a person spends on dining out could pay for several bednets, each protecting two children in a lowincome country from malaria for about two years. Utilitarian thinking underlies most of these phrases, and many individuals believe they are morally obligated to increase the happiness and decrease the unhappiness in the world.
Because we lack omniscience and never know for certain what the outcomes of the actions open to us will be, actualoutcome utilitarians will say. However, late in the book, he does lapse a bit in thinking that, possibly, he has the best theory in his grasp. From a utilitarian perspective, it certainly could be. By doing so publicly, hopefully others will see you, and agree the law is unjust and work to change it. Shaw presents his rather classical portrait of utilitarianism as. It strives to achieve the greatest good for the greatest number while creating the least amount of harm or preventing the greatest amount of suffering. The best books on ethical problems five books expert. Pdf utilitarianism and the ethics of war, written by william h. Shaws utilitarianism and the ethics of war is a terrific book that will enlighten readers interested in moral problems about warfare as well as friends and foes of utilitarian moral theory. Utilitarianism, act and rule internet encyclopedia of. Only people who think a law so unjust they are willing to suffer sanction will engage in it. Still, from the perspective of either the just war or the utilitarian approach, we can appreciate lackeys concern with proportionality. Marquette books llc of phoenix, arizona usa, is proud to announce publication of the savvy investors guide for doing business in china, a book designed to help people especially investors, business executives and college students in america and other western countries learn about, invest and do business in the peoples republic of china. This article discusses utilitarian ethical and philosophical theory.
When there are multiple choices with different utilities, or wen utilities conflict, we should always pick the greatest one. In contrast to the utilitarian perspective, the deontological view presented in the writings of immanuel kant purports that having a moral intent and following the right rules is a better path to ethical conduct than achieving the right results. Stephen nathanson, emeritus professor, northeastern university, usa in this important new work, professor shaw reflects not simply upon what states and their leaders actually. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war war, conflict and. List of books and articles about utilitarianism online.
He has also suggested using pacifism and just war theory as secondary rules or principles. Analyzing the perspective on abortion from a utilitarian view is quite hot and cold. Decamp professor of bioethics at princeton university, and a laureate professor at the centre for applied philosophy and public ethics at the university of melbourne. The first section of the chapter is largely descriptive as mill begins by saying that throughout history, one of the major obstacles to the reception of utility. Utilitarianism holds that the most ethical choice is the one that will produce the greatest good for the greatest number. Shaw, utilitarianism and the ethics of war routledge. Dakota kasapi okicize wowapi in april 1863 after the u. Free ethics utilitarianism in relation to the war on iraq.
For various reasons, i prefer the expectedoutcome standard, but the practical upshot of this intramural debate is not great. Although the authors of utilitarian theory primarily agree on, and advocate the concept of utility, a prominent conflict is evident in relation to the way utilitarian principles should be applied. Utilitarianism does not concern itself with the nature of the act. This book offers a detailed utilitarian analysis of the ethical issues involved in war. This works out nicely from a ruleutilitarian perspective.
A utilitarian approach is the greatest good for the greatest number. By calling him an evolutionary humanist, spender suggests that aldous took a single, fixed intellectual position, whereas he changed his opinionseven reversed themin important ways, and was. The first, and shortest, portion of shaws book deals mainly with utilitarianism, the second with war. Any given action is sometimes permissible, sometimes mandatory, sometimes prohibited for a utilitarian based. Dec 16, 2010 a utilitarian approach is the greatest good for the greatest number. It is part of the overarching ethical theory of consequentialism, which is the study of an individuals actions and the effect those actions had on the situation and others. Absolutism, utilitarianism, and moral military decision making. Search the worlds most comprehensive index of fulltext books. He then turns to what he calls the utilitarian war principle. It is the only moral framework that can be used to justify military force or war. After properly emphasizing the conscience of the huxleys, stephen spender nyr, march 25 offers a sketch of aldous that vastly oversimplifies that very complex man.
Utilitarianism is the ethical notion that what is useful is good psy 533, 2017. In other words, a country would not need a just war cause other than having the right intentions and making sure the war would produce the greatest. The law of war has developed and will continue to develop driven by two radically different perspectives, that of the utilitarian or warrior and that of the humanitarian. Shaws utilitarianism and the ethics of war masterfully develops utilitarian prescriptions about when wars should be fought and about what are the rules that commanders and lowerranked military personnel should follow in wars. An ethical philosophy in which the happiness of the greatest number of people in the society is considered the greatest good. Agents capture a suspect who, they believe, has information about where the bomb is planted. According to this philosophy, an action is morally right if its consequences lead to happiness absence of pain, and wrong if it ends in unhappiness pain since the link between actions and their happy or unhappy outcomes depends on the circumstances, no moral.
Finally, in the late twentieth century and the early twentyfirst century, peter singer has also applied utilitarianism to a variety of moral problems. On occasion, however, a philosophical theory can alter the way people think. Utilitarianism and recourse to war utilitas cambridge core. In this we weigh the pros and cons of each situation at hand.
Utilitarianism and the ethics of war war, conflict and ethics. William shaw has developed utilitarian war principles uwp to look at both these from a utilitarian perspective, as previously they have not been addressed. That is the domain of deontology and to a lesser extent virtue ethics. Utilitarianism is a normative ethical theory that places the locus of right and wrong solely on the outcomes consequences of choosing one actionpolicy over other actionspolicies.
Peter albert david singer ac born 6 july 1946 is an australian moral philosopher. Looking at the fifth chapter of mills utilitarianism in more depth, we can deduce many ideas that also relate to the war on iraq and whether it is a just or ethical war. Moore, in his principia ethica 1903, presented a version of utilitarianism in which he rejected the traditional equating of good with pleasure. Realists are noted in the book as having multiple views within the theory that slightly differ from one another, but tend to believe the same thing in the end. Is war morally permissible in a utilitarian point of view. The essay first appeared as a series of three articles published in frasers magazine in 1861. Utilitarianism and war and peace flashcards quizlet. For the architectural theory, see form follows function. For the purpose of this essay, an act utilitarian perspective will be assumed, focussing on the recent war within iraq.
For with war come not only conquest and hostility, but also economic. The study of the ethics of war is brimming with cases taken from the realist perspective, where war among states is neither right nor wrong and is viewed outside of morality all together, and. Although he focuses upon bushs abuse of just war theory, lackeys criticism of the gulf war can be read equally plausibly as a utilitarian critique. Despite the enormous impact that war and the threat of war have had on human wellbeing, utilitarians have had surprisingly little to say about when, if ever, we may fight wars. Especially impressive are shaws explanations of how utilitarianism underwrites the principles of just war theory. He discusses the view of noncombatants as having the. In other words, a country would not need a just war cause other than having the right. It is also the most common approach to moral reasoning used in business because of the way in which it accounts for costs and benefits. Shaw, utilitarianism and the ethics of war, routledge, 2016, 183pp. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war 1st edition william. Utilitarianism, a theory proposed by david hume 17111776 but given definitive formulation by. Although different varieties of utilitarianism admit different characterizations, the basic idea behind all of them is to in some sense maximize utility, which is often defined in terms of wellbeing or related concepts.
The second key concept of utilitarianism is that we judge moral actions by the consequences they produce. Although it goes against the tide of recent work in the field, a utilitarian approach to the ethics of war illuminates old questions in new ways by showing how a. They think that they are falling for short termism, and will get a pleasure boost but in the long run will live to regret it. May 08, 2012 applied ethics is the application of moral theory to the real world. Mills book utilitarianism is a classic exposition and defense of utilitarianism in ethics. History some 270 dakota men were moved from mankato, minnesota, to a prison at camp mcclellan in davenport, iowa. The perspective on abortion from a utilitarian view bartleby.
The four horsemen of revelation 6 riding out to conquer and fight, to impoverish and to kill, are the realistic images of war. He specialises in applied ethics and approaches ethical issues from a secular, utilitarian perspective. Just war utilitarianism approach in uncategorized on december 16, 2010 at 1. I first read the five books that we are going to talk about here 25 years ago, which was the beginning of a burgeoning of. Sanger, a somber bush says terrorism cannot prevail, n. Discussion of this question has been dominated by realism, pacifism and just war theory. Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that determines right from wrong by focusing on outcomes. This volume contains selections from his books and articles. For a discussion of john stuart mill s book utilitarianism, see utilitarianism book. Shaw, utilitarianism and the ethics of war philpapers. Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Dakota war of 1862, after the hanging of thirtyeight dakota men in the largest mass execution in u. Central intelligence agency gets wind of a plot to set off a dirty bomb in a major american city.
The reaction against utilitarianism was a second romanticism, in which the fight against social injustice and the opposition to the actual theories of the dismal science played a much smaller part than the urge to escape from the present, whose problems the antiutilitarians had no ability and no desire to solve, into the irrarionalism of burke, coleridge, and german romanticism. Naturally, there is a broad range of fundamental ethical questions regarding war. Civil disobedience is not a getoutofjail free card for the popular. The utilitarian approach assesses an action in terms of its consequences or outcomes. Pdf utilitarianism has a fairly bad reputation in military ethics. Herbert spencer developed an evolutionary utilitarian ethics in which the principles of ethical living are based on the evolutionary changes of organic development. Generally, consequentialists and act utilitarians may claim that if military. He specialises in applied ethics and approaches ethical issues from a secular. The dark rule utilitarian argument for science piracy slate. Shaw hence argues that although just war theory on the surface. As such, it moves beyond the scope of ones own interests and takes into account the interests of others. Utilitarianism is a family of consequentialist ethical theories that promotes actions that maximize happiness and wellbeing for the. According to this philosophy, an action is morally right if its consequences lead to happiness absence of pain, and wrong if it ends in unhappiness pain. Our teams are looking into this as we speak and we hope to be able to resolve this issue as soon as possible.
1263 1244 1148 1056 1317 1503 1081 93 1422 948 238 428 125 460 1171 218 313 574 1102 1260 614 1205 215 501 752 1462 267 1281 592